Sunday, August 23, 2026


 

In spite of some difficult mobility issues now and after 30 years as an administrator at CCSF and as the Vice-Chancellor of Governmental Affairs, Leslie Smith continues to champion City College for all!  This past Monday, August 17, she, Rick Baum, and I met with Mahanaz Ebadi of Supervisor Dorsey's staff to talk about the importance of keeping campuses--specifically the Downtown Campus, which is in Supervisor Dorsey's district--open.  Of course I also mentioned 750 Eddy, which was closed abruptly in 2015 for seismic retrofitting, paid for with our taxes, which was never done these past 11 years.  


Thursday, March 26, 2026

 



March 6, 2026

I just signed this petition.

I wish all of our campuses were still open, but I wonder about this:  Since the Ocean Campus and the Mission Campus need students, is it possible that students who can no longer enroll in the Downtown center will add to the Ocean or Mission enrollment?  

In spite of my worry about the needs of the Ocean and Mission campuses, I signed.

This downtown S.F. college campus to close after low enrollment triggers loss of state funds

By Nanette Asimov,Staff WriterMarch 6, 2026

Gift Article

City College of San Francisco will close its 47-year-old campus at Fourth and Mission streets this summer and move its culinary, fashion and language classes to other under-enrolled locations, including to the school’s Chinatown campus, the Chronicle has learned.

The campus at 88 Fourth St., one of six primary City College sites around the city, is set to lose more than $2 million in state funding next year because it enrolls the equivalent of just 152 full-time students — far short of the 1,000 required to continue receiving money from the state. 

Because of that and the cost of maintaining the nine-story campus, “our leadership team has made the difficult decision not to schedule classes at the Downtown Center for the fall semester,” City College Chancellor Kimberlee Messina emailed employees Friday, noting that “there will be no job losses because of this change.”

The Downtown Center’s closure this summer will be the latest vacancy in the ongoing exodus of businesses and other tenants from the city’s once-vibrant core, which civic leaders have struggled to reverse since the end of the pandemic. Amid some signs of improvement, more than 30% of office buildings remained empty at the end of 2025. 

City College owns the 84,000-square-foot building and will look for “potential partnerships with other educational institutions, community-based organizations, the city and other partners” that might move into the building, Messina said. 

Aliya Chisti, chair of the college’s Board of Trustees, called the Downtown campus a “valued part of City College’s presence in the community, and its future will continue to be an important conversation.”

Established in 1979, City College Downtown enrolls more than 900 part-time students studying food service, fashion, Romance languages and English. Last year, the campus was among a dozen downtown colleges and universities — with nearly 13,000 in-person students altogether — identified by the Chronicle, even as city leaders expressed hope of attracting a new college to revitalize the area. Each school, including City College’s Downtown Center, urged the mayor’s office to instead invest in schools already there.

But even then, it may have been too late for the Downtown Center.

The campus has long been known for its baking program and other culinary courses. For years, the students operated their popular “Educated Palate” restaurant on the corner of Fourth and Mission. When the pandemic forced the restaurant’s closure, students opened “EP,” a weekly pop-bake shop on the site.

But the energy behind the school’s baking program came mainly from Elizabeth Riehle, known as Chef Betsy, who is retiring after this semester. Next fall, her program will be consolidated with other food service classes at City College’s main campus on Frida Kahlo Way in the Ingleside neighborhood. 

That would decimate the downtown site. The entire student body already equates to just 152 full-timers, Vice Chancellor David Yee told the college trustees on Feb. 12.

Unlike City College’s other campuses, the Downtown Center is directly approved by the state, said Chris Ferguson, an executive vice chancellor with the California Community College chancellor’s office. As a result, the state requires this particular campus to enroll at least 1,000 full-time equivalent students as a condition of receiving $2.2 million a year. Pandemic and other state funding protections allowed the Downtown Center to keep the funding for several years, even as enrollment dropped below the threshold. 

But those protections will expire on July 1.  

For City College, attracting new students has been one of its most vexing, and costly, dilemmas.

A decade ago, City College enrolled the equivalent of 22,541 full-time students across all of its six campuses, state records show. Today, records show just 9,172 full-time equivalent students for this fall, a 59% drop. Yee’s updated presentation to the City College trustees reveals an even lower number: 7,355.

The college’s enrollment plunge has led the state to freeze funding for City College at 2024-25 levels until more students show up. But the Downtown campus is not fully protected by this minimal funding guarantee because it operates at the state’s discretion.

To try and reverse their overall enrollment problem, City College officials are challenging themselves to attract 800 full-time equivalent students to each of three campuses: Chinatown (808 Kearny St.), Mission (1125 Valencia St.) and John Adams (1860 Hayes St.), according to this year’s budget.

That will be a heavy lift, requiring City College to more than double enrollment across all three sites to 2,700 full-time equivalent students. Currently, there are just 1,438. So college officials are eyeing classes with low enrollment and considering where to shift their funding.

Enter the Downtown campus. 

Not only is it far from student housing, but the English-language classes it offers must also compete with new online language apps. The rise of ICE has also scattered many English learners from in-person classes across the entire system. The Downtown campus is also increasingly isolated, sitting around the corner from the shuttered San Francisco Centre mall.

Chisti, the trustees’ chair, noted that the campus has been important for English learners and other immigrant communities for years. 

“As the college navigates enrollment and funding challenges, the focus is on making sure students continue to have access to classes and services,” she said.

Friday, September 5, 2025

 https://www.inglesidelight.com/balboa-reservoir-developers-hold-meeting-as-work-starts/




 https://www.kemilyvisuals.com/proofing/ccsf-90th-celebration-by-kemily-visuals




These are the photos taken by a real professional at the 90th Anniversary of CCSF celebration.  


Email: one you check most
Password: BigMilestone90years!!!

Friday, August 22, 2025




City College had a wonderful celebration for it's 90th birthday yesterday, August 21, 2025 in the Steam Building I hope I showed here when it first opened on December 12, 2024, just before I became an official member of the Citizens' Bond Oversight Committee.   We'd been invited to dress as one of the decades or as the future--but that invitation came in last minute.  I thought maybe I'd have time to create a pair of earrings, but that idea morphed into a collar with planks promising a progressive, positive future for CCSF, with bots helping but not taking over.  

 

Tuesday, June 10, 2025

 https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/city-college-union-incident-board-meeting-20361558.php

https://www.pressreader.com/usa/san-francisco-chronicle-late-edition/20250607/281586656545141?srsltid=AfmBOopb_N8alICxcIoR9P46CDhGH8Q5lQK001RJsplNWO1NpjLL3XTX

 I believe in and support labor unions, but things have gotten pretty crazy at CCSF!  


The only ones who will speak to the mainstream press do not share the AFT 2121's views.  I admire them for having the courage to speak out on the verbal abuse Maria Salazar-Colon spewed to Abigail Bornstein, who as far as I've ever witnessed, has always expressed her unpopular opinions with courage and civility.  (Of course, people who don't share her views perceive what she says as bullying and show contempt for her, obviously regretting that "nevertheless, she persists."  

  I remember an earlier BOT meeting when Maria Salazar-Colon spoke angrily and threateningly at some group of people (COPE?), and I asked about her.  I was told that she was "that way," not a very nice person but not certifiably insane.   I'm also shocked that she's still the president of the CCSF chapter of SEIU!   I'm also appalled that when she was spewing venom at Abigail Bornstein, she wasn't stopped. If she's mentally ill, that's unfortunate.  But of course, the trustees have a responsibility to prevent verbal abuse and f-bombs. I worked to elect Anita Martinez, who's now president of the Board of Trustees.  I like and respect her, but I don't like or respect her letting this verbal abuse continue.



Friday, June 6, 2025

 Can it be true that it was right after his performance evaluation that Carlos Cortez abruptly left his position as chancellor of the San Diego Community College District?


https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/city-college-chancellor-search-crisis-20357825.php


Friday, May 30, 2025

 The Board of Trustees did not appoint Carlos Cortez as the next chancellor as was expected and even announced.


https://www.inglesidelight.com/city-college-leaders-chancellor-contract/

The Ingleside Light quotes Mary Bravewoman, whose job it is to slant things so it appears that the faculty are in agreement when they are not.  I believe in unions, but of course they're a political body.

Last night at the Board of Trustees meeting this is what she said:


"You've already heard from us, this college community, and the number of people that are standing back there. Multiply them by tens. They represent the entire college community. And we have been waiting for months," Bravewoman said. "This is an embarrassment."

Bravewoman continued, "I don't understand why there is a lack of leadership and direction. We have a clear choice in front of us. You heard from the community, you heard from students, you heard from faculty. What the actual fuck is the hold up? This is an embarrassment."

I certainly haven't kept up on this.  I didn't even realize that Anita Martinez, not Alan Wong, was the current president of the board.  

This final statement in the article stunned me!  

The new chancellor is expected to stabilize the school's finances and increase the number of students served.


Stabilizing the school's finances is what Chancellor Bailey was blamed for.  The new chancellor is expected to side with the union.  

Monday, April 21, 2025

Madeline Mueller, Department Chair of CCSF's Theater Department,  deserves a lot of credit for getting out the word about City College's production of Arthur Miller's The Crucible, which was staged at what I think of as the Herbst Theater at 401 Van Ness, where the United Nations Charter was signed June 26, 1945.   It's really the Taube Atrium Theater next door to the War Memorial Opera House, and I guess it's distinguished from the War Memorial Opera House by the name War Memorial Veterans Building.  I'm happy to report that there was a huge turn out.  Patricia Miller directed the production.  I invited Erika Delacorte and Sandra Pulido for their birthday gift.  (Moments, not merchandise...)





 

Saturday, January 25, 2025




 Here's what I tried to post on Beth Ericson's Facebook page:

Tina Martin
Thanks for posting this, Beth, and for your brilliant idea of comparing its past and present use. I've been horrified when I've gone by and seen how it's being used. I shared this with Peter Hartlaub, who did an article on places in SF where movies have been filmed. I told him that "Sister Act 2" was filmed in 1992 at 750 Eddy, and I told him about the abrupt closure in 2015. I also shared this link: https://beyondchron.org/abandoned-tenderloin-ccsf.../
Abandoned Tenderloin CCSF building is Magnet for Drug Dealers - Beyond Chron
BEYONDCHRON.ORG
Abandoned Tenderloin CCSF building is Magnet for Drug Dealers - Beyond Chron
Abandoned Tenderloin CCSF building is Magnet for Drug Dealers - Beyond Chron
  • Like
  • Reply
  • Remove Preview
Tina Martin
He wrote back showing a great interest and saying the Chronicle should do a story on this, but there was never any follow-up that I saw.
Now, 10 years after that unconscionably abrupt closure, it's on our list for the seismic upgrades! From what I see in the Bond Project update that was presented at my first meeting with the Citizens' Bond Oversight Committee--750 Eddy very hastily shown in spite of our speaking up and showing concern--the wait is for funding from the CCCCO--the California Community Colleges Chancellor's Office! It's budgeted at $20M, with funds coming from Prop A 2005 and Prop A 2020 and then (when???) from the State.

But I can't see it!  Maybe it will appear belatedly?


Thursday, January 23, 2025


 Here's what the Ingleside neighborhood newspaper Inglesidelight has to say about the SF-CCSF connection:


Leveraging City College

Lurie plans to stabilize and increase enrollment by working with City College of San Francisco's leadership, faculty, union and students to advocate for additional funding, expand workforce development programs, reduce waitlists for core classes and create new partnerships with local businesses. He wants to align the curriculum with emerging industries and provide robust support services to make the college a premiere destination for education and career training.

On its way and set to open to the public by 2027 is the construction of the Diego Rivera Theater and the return of Rivera’s huge priceless fresco “Pan American Unity." Lurie predicts that the Diego Rivera Theater will become a cultural landmark that draws in visitors from across the city and beyond. To achieve this, Lurie said he’d work with the college community, the city’s tourist sector and local businesses to market the attraction with tactics like highlighting the venue as an events center and will work to improve transit access and community programming around the theater.


https://www.inglesidelight.com/

Sunday, December 1, 2024


On the subject of the SF-CCSF connection, I should mention the Citizens' Bond Oversight Committee.  CCSF Trustee Susan Solomon lives in the same co-op as Betty Traynor, Head of SDA and VP of OWL (Older Women's League).  She let Betty know that City College needed someone on the CBOC to represent senior organizations, and Betty brought this up with the OWL Board, who thought of me.  Melanie broached the subject, and I said no.  But after discussing it with Leslie Simon, Chris Hanson, and Susan Solomon herself, I decided that there really was a need, and the bickering between one part of the faculty and another wouldn't necessarily affect us.


The picture above is a shot of the interview.  


More later.
 

Friday, October 4, 2024

 Although I've been a strong union supporter at CCSF (and of unions generally), I think it's healthy that people are questioning union decisions, specifically its defiance of state guidelines--guidelines we should work on changing but can't really defy and still save our college (even in its downsize).  

One of the most brilliant people expressing his view on what was the Electronic Faculty Forum (EFF) is Richard Baum.  Here his brilliance doesn't shine because he's asking a question, and the answer is obvious!  Here's what he sent out today:


Since 2017, Gohar Momjian has been a vice president of the ACCJC. On the ACCJC website, she is described "As Associate Vice Chancellor of Institutional Development, and Accreditation Liaison Officer (ALO) for City College of San Francisco from July 2012 until June 2015..."
 In a deposition occurring on June 9, 2014, Momjian was asked the following question and gave the response below. 
Q. Okay. So the AFT was a hindrance to City College coming into compliance with the accreditation standards;  true?
Mr. Goldberg: Objection; leading.
The Witness:  In my opinion, yes.
Momjian did not provide any explanation for this answer.  I wrote to her asking that she inform us as to how “AFT was a hindrance to City College coming into compliance with accreditation standards.” She never responded.

Personally, I like people who respond and resent people who don't.  But of course it's obvious that the AFT opposed CCSF's coming into compliance with the accreditation standards.  I think it has even called the ACCJC a "rogue" organization.


Tuesday, August 6, 2024

 Nanette Asimov has often been maligned by CCSF faculty as unfair to our college, and this was reflected in something she wrote for the SF Chronicle when she was reporting on AI for students.

https://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/reporter-s-notebook-ai-helped-steer-19599871.php

Below the picture of her on a panel in 2012, when CCSF had been given Show Cause ( proof of why you shouldn't be closed down) and her taking notes at a rally, I've pasted what she says in reference to the blowback.  




Now comes 80 words of personal stuff. I’m supposed to describe an instance where I had to disclose difficult information.

So I write about a time when, in my stories for the Chronicle, I revealed financial problems at a beloved local college. In those stories, I explained, an accrediting agency complained about the college’s management, and the college defended itself.

Next up, according to my AI counselor, I need 60 words explaining the backlash or criticism I received.

I say that, as an impartial messenger, I was caught between both sides: faculty furious that my stories made the college look bad, and accreditors ticked at me for airing complaints about them. I write that it hurt when people stopped taking my calls and someone spit at me.